from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you conceptualize the internet?

by vicbrooker on 7/19/13, 4:51 AM with 1 comments

I'm currently sitting in a class discussion at my university discussing the relationship between the internet and privacy/IP law.

Everyone here are law students and the most common view of the internet as a physical place - the lecturer recently wrote an article asking whether the internet should be seen as a meadow or a series of rooms.

My answer is neither. I don't think that using physical metaphors are going to accurately represent what the internet is and how it works. I think it's actually a bit dangerous once we start making laws off this assumption too.

So my question is, how do you all see the internet? What's the fairest way to conceptualise data, how it's made and who can use it?

I can't help but think that asking here is going to be better than asking the law faculty :-/

TL;DR: How should we think of the internet? Should it be treated as a physical 'place' or is this wrong? How do we explain it to people without a tech background (lawyers, young children etc.)?

  • by terrykohla on 7/19/13, 4:14 PM

    I think that seeing it as a physical place helps conceptualize a virtual world.

    I'm neither a programmer or a developer.

    When I go online, it's like I'm out on the street. I'm exposed to others. I can interact with others. I can walk into a shop or a bank and conduct business. I can walk into a theater or an arcade. I can walk into someone's place, an open house or a private house. But it's not physical, it's all virtual, it's all built with code, data and information.