from Hacker News

Harvard chemist talks about the problem of solving problems

by jcarden on 9/6/12, 6:25 AM with 19 comments

  • by rubidium on 9/6/12, 12:59 PM

    Q: "What problems are being neglected?"

    Whitesides: "I don't have strong feelings about that. There are so many problems in the world"

    I've was recently at a conference with a bunch of Nobel Prize winners in Physics and Chemistry. I was asking them a similar question, and some version of Whitesides reply was what I almost always got.

  • by 6ren on 9/6/12, 8:00 AM

      it's very easy in academic science to end up working on projects that are just
      little extensions of previously known stuff, and that's sort of a waste of time.
  • by __Joker on 9/6/12, 7:58 AM

    I get page not found error for the op's submission. But I assume this is the page which was submitted, http://www.technologyreview.in/biomedicine/41024/
  • by 001sky on 9/6/12, 6:44 AM

    Technology Review: What's the problem you have most wanted to solve and haven't been able to?

    Whitesides: There's an intellectual problem, which is the origin of life. The origin of life has the characteristic that there's something in there as a chemist, which I just don't understand. I don't understand how you go from a system that's random chemicals to something that becomes, in a sense, a Darwinian set of reactions that are getting more complicated spontaneously. I just don't understand how that works. So that's a scientific problem.

    --This is a rare, intellectually honest view of Evolution. Notice, there is reasonable doubt. However so constrained.