from Hacker News

Ask HN: What features do you think are missing from Goodreads?

by imheretolearn on 7/28/23, 1:57 AM with 7 comments

What features do you think for a good book reading community are missing on reddit, 4chan etc?

  • by mcdonje on 7/28/23, 3:08 AM

    I've been on Goodreads, but not in a while. So, take my opinions with a grain of salt.

    - First and foremost, protection from review trolls. Goodreads star ratings are influential, impactful, and unreliable.

    - A flexible yet coherent system for grouping books. Maybe multiple systems. For instance, I have trouble finding hard sci-fi books because most sci-fi has fantasy elements and hard sci-fi isn't the most popular subgenre. Some books are genre-benders. Sometimes a "subgenre" is better characterized as an intersection. Maybe something tag based, but the tags are categorized.

    - I'm not interested in popular reviewers. I'm interested in reviewers who like the things I like.

  • by bwb on 7/29/23, 12:01 PM

    I think Goodreads might be improved if it had more community areas that got people within small active groups to foster community and HQ interaction... maybe a reimagining of book clubs for the online world. And maybe capping groups at ~50 or smaller dunbar numbers and trying to piggyback off real-world groups.

    I also like Story Graph doing buddy reads. I think that is a cool concept, but not sure how successful it is.

    I created Shepherd.com, but I am focused purely on book discovery and exploration, so everything I am doing is around how to find books you will love.

    I am trying to develop book recommendation channels so that readers can subscribe to different people they find interesting and keep that type of concept going forward (while helping authors). The subscriptions will be email-based, and the first step toward that goal is launching next month.

    For now I ask authors to share 5 books they love around a topic, theme, and mood. Then I connect books in cool ways.

    For example, here is our hard sci fi shelf: https://shepherd.com/bookshelf/hard-science-fiction

    Genres are hard, as getting data on books is a mess. The industry standards are shit and don't do a good job. So you have to crowdsource data or something.

  • by fhaldridge7 on 7/28/23, 8:59 AM

    The reviews on goodreads need to be moderated, some comments have nothing to do with a book review