from Hacker News

Ask HN: If you write/draw using AI is the intellectual property still yours?

by adelarsq on 1/25/23, 12:53 PM with 3 comments

  • by verdverm on 1/25/23, 1:20 PM

    The jury is still out and it will depend on numerous facts: local laws (many tbd), ToS, court rulings (tbd), does the result infringe on existing IP, is the writing copyrighted or part of a patent... In the US, iirc, patents by AI are denied.

    tl;dr, no one really knows yet and it will change with time

  • by mejutoco on 1/25/23, 3:13 PM

    I see a possible contradiction between 2 common arguments I see regarding AI image generation:

    a - ip laws don't apply to AI because it is learning from many examples, like a human does (here AI is a human)

    b - I retain copyright because I am just using a tool (here AI is not a human)

    It does not seem consistent to have both.

  • by reportgunner on 1/25/23, 1:13 PM

    Only if you make it an NFT.