from Hacker News

What’s Wrong with US Broadband?

by ilarum on 11/17/22, 3:29 PM with 12 comments

• by samarthr1 on 11/17/22, 3:47 PM

  Here in urban India, I get 33 mbps symmetric for leser than 5 USD a month[1], and a 33 tb data cap.

  [1] https://www.jio.com/selfcare/plans/fiber/jiofiber-prepaid-mo...

• by johnthuss on 11/17/22, 3:36 PM

  "In short, this is what’s wrong with broadband in America. It’s expensive. Most people can’t choose their carrier. They add bogus charges."

  To this list I would add that lack of choice of speeds, whether you want a faster speed or want to pay less for a slower speed. There is simply a lack of choice.

• by tomwheeler on 11/17/22, 8:32 PM

  What's wrong with US broadband, in my case, is that it simply doesn't exist. Some people lament having a choice of one carrier, but I have a choice of zero carriers who provide broadband service (as currently defined by the FCC).

  I live in a county of approximately one million people and the neighborhood adjacent to mine, including a house less than 200 feet away, has cable internet with 300 Mbps service. I've been paying Universal Service Fund fees for years (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Service_Fund) but I had a faster DSL connection 20 years ago.

• by uni_rule on 11/17/22, 5:09 PM

  Somehow they have too much regulation to allow competition to build out but also not enough regulation to not be absolute shitheads to their territorially captive customers. The cable cartel specifically has never overbuilt due to the fact that outside of mergers and other unnatural growth they made towns sign exclusivity agreements back when all these systems were was a means of accessing porn and HBO, but once they got broadband faster than DSL they were able to pummel the previous telephone providers into the ground before doing regulatory capture enough to prevent any upstart from possibly building fiber lines or whatever without besting them in hand to hand combat.

• by legitster on 11/17/22, 4:08 PM

  So, I've talked to lots of people who have moved out of the country (Germany, Eastern Europe, SE Asia, S America), and nearly all of them have complained about the local internet options (some areas may be significantly cheaper, but quality is a concern).

  So I can't tell if this is actually a uniquely American problem or just us Americans thinking our problems are the center of the world.

• by masterof0 on 11/17/22, 4:01 PM

  I would love some choice, in my building I can only get xFinity, or a very slow ATT DSL connection. That's what is wrong.

• by zeruch on 11/17/22, 4:20 PM

  Everything.

• by programmer_dude on 11/17/22, 4:12 PM

  It seems unrestricted capitalism and the free market eventually leads to a complete take over by monopolies. Case in point: USA.