from Hacker News

Ask HN: How to find a small town to relocate for remote work?

by Townley on 8/15/22, 2:57 AM with 550 comments

Curious to hear the community’s perspective on where our next move should be.

I’m an engineering manager at a fully remote US company with long-term plans to stay (and even if not, no desire to return to the office regularly). I don’t drive but like to walk to the supermarket and restaurants. My wife doesn’t like living in a big city, so we’re in the burbs within walking distance of a little “downtown” area.

It’s a bit of an unhappy medium because the homes we want still cost $1M, yet it’s a long and limited walk. Plus we’re ready for something new. We’d likely both be happier in a town, living just off some Main Street with 20 or so shops. The city is great but honestly I don’t need more than a good diner, a supermarket, and a friendly bar. Nice to haves are a pleasant climate (not too cold), an airport within an hour or so, and decent public schools.

I’m asking here because I hear so much about NYC/SF tech workers being set loose by remote work and leaving. I’ve experienced this with colleagues relocating to SC, Lancaster PA, small towns in Maryland… etc.

Any ideas on whether this mid-sized town dream exists, ideas for cities, and/or how we’d go about finding it?

  • by rswerve on 8/15/22, 3:22 AM

    College towns. Pick some states, and go visit towns with colleges in them. They'll have restaurants and groceries, and those faculty kids have to go to school somewhere. Internet should be passable, too. They won't be the cheapest small town option, but houses should come in well below a million bucks.

    The one town you mention, Lancaster, PA, is a model of the type.

  • by subpixel on 8/15/22, 12:19 PM

    We recently did the same, though in our case opportunity drove our decision and not careful consideration. We got quite lucky under the circumstances.

    My observation, fwiw, is that the American small town, self-sufficient and independent from a neighboring city, is a dying breed.

    Not all small towns will die the same way or on the same schedule. But here are some things to think about.

    - Is there a tourist draw? Do short-term rentals address this opportunity? Every vacation rental is a unit unavailable to the local salaried population and where we live this cannibalizes the fabric of the small town.

    - Is the local industry durable? That could be a university, it could be timber, it could be a BMW factory 90 minutes away, it could be a fishing fleet. Where we live the local industry will be eradicated in our lifetime due to climate change. And the state university system is retracting, not growing.

    - Do the local schools suffer under-enrollment? Where we live they do not, but neighboring towns have so many retirees and houses turned into short-term rentals that the schools are threatened.

    In short, the internet means there are no undiscovered places, and the economics can undermine what makes a place special in the first place. Add to that some places are going to be significantly impacted by global warming.

    Today we live in a sort of paradise but we are aware that it may not be our forever home, if such a thing exists.

  • by throwaway787544 on 8/15/22, 5:23 AM

    I live in the outskirts of a poor rural town in NY. We have 2 bars, some restaurants, a coffee shop, a fast food chain, some dollar stores, a grocery store, hardware store, antiques, gas stations, etc, Library and a little theater, farmers market on weekends. River runs nearby with a put-in for kayaks and fishing. Biggest town/city nearby with big box stores is about 45 minutes. They have fiber internet here but it's very expensive and the 300/20 Mbps is fine for me. 5G varies by region & provider.

    Honestly... It's kind of great. The people are nice, the scenery is gorgeous, it's pretty quiet, and most everything you need is right in town. Since the community is so poor, all the housing is cheap. Nearby towns are all bought up as second homes for expats. Everything outside town is an old farm.

    The worst thing about the place is it's a minimum 2 hour drive to anywhere, and having a car is mandatory to get here. But if you have everything you need, there's no need to leave. There is no Uber/Lyft/Instacart/GrubHub, don't expect any startups here. Cell service outside of towns is mostly nonexistent. Also know that none of your old friends will ever visit because it's way too inconvenient.

    The only things I miss are "big city" things and more people around into the same things I'm into. And an international airport would be nice, but it's not like I was flying around the world every weekend before.

  • by rlawson on 8/15/22, 12:28 PM

    Let me give you the scoop on the Carolina's. I'm a developer living in the upstate of SC. I am an agnostic liberal which makes me a rarity but I was born here so I can go under the radar thanks to my deep melodious southern accent.

    Pros

      - Great climate 10 out of 12 months
      - Friendly people
      - Lots of outdoor activities
      - Beautiful beaches (Fripp Island and Kiawah especially)
      - Low cost housing (altho going up rapidly)
      - Greenville and Charleston are very nice
    
    Cons

      - Heart of MAGA land (this may be a pro depending on your politics)
      - First question is about what church you go to
      - Can still be shockingly racist at times (altho getting much better)
      - Weak zoning so sprawling construction and walkable areas limited
      - Food choices can be limited for vegans/vegetarians
      - July/August - the heat and humidity are rough
  • by blahedo on 8/15/22, 5:19 AM

    What you describe is a perfect literal match for my town (Farmville, VA) up to your ask for a "mid-sized town". We're a town of 8000, half of which are the university students. I like it a lot (and you might well consider it, email me if you like) but it's not at all what I'd consider "mid-sized", and I'm not sure you'll get all the other stuff you describe if you aim for "mid-sized".

    But yes, right on, 20 or so shops, walkable downtown with houses an easy walk away, a few good restaurants (including a great diner! :) and at least two friendly bars. Good internet connection if you're in town. I don't get in my car for weeks at a time---and that's probably your hardest item, because anywhere between "pretty small town" and "sizeable city with good public transit" living without a car (in the US) is going to be very very difficult. (Even in a place like Farmville, you don't need the car around town but you'll need it to get out of town.)

    ETA: I see from your profile you're in DC now. Come visit! We're only 3 hours away ;)

  • by Arete314159 on 8/15/22, 4:41 AM

    Make an excel spreadsheet, list the things you want in a town. Then start researching towns and list whether they have those things, point by point.

    One thing I would suggest is that if you're moving, bear in mind that climate change is making some previously pleasant places much more unpleasant. Look at recent years of fire data, flood data, air quality from smoke, drought, heat, etc.

    And finally, make sure the place you're moving to is going to have ample, clean fresh water, and no other environmental problems looming. Don't move to Vegas. Don't move to Salt Lake City. Don't move anywhere that is going to lose power if Lake Mead or Lake Powell dry up.

    You can search EWG for your prospective towns. Be aware that many, many towns in the US have way higher PFAS / PFOA / etc. than you probably want. Many have very high levels of other contaminants as well. Some whole-house filters can filter that out but they're expensive.

    Here's the EWG report for a sample California town: https://www.ewg.org/tapwater/system.php?pws=CA0110009

    Search "town name + superfund". Search "town name" + "pollution". Search "town name" + {various natural disasters}. Search "town name" + "smoke". Search "town name" + "smell". Search "town name" + "water."

    Go visit everywhere that's on your short list. Ask people about the town.

    Good luck!

  • by CSMastermind on 8/15/22, 4:29 AM

    > this mid-sized town dream exists

    Of course, but you should figure out what specifically you're looking for beyond what you've described.

    Do you care about tax implications? Are you planning to rent or own a home? Do you have friends or family in any of these areas?

    If you haven't traveled much I'd recommend doing it.

    This is the most accurate map breaking down regions in the United States in my opinion: https://i.redd.it/q79o3qo8zz991.png

    Just for reference, here is a 'cleaner' version that most people like: https://i.redd.it/y4pxyq5eslh51.png

    > ... and/or how we’d go about finding it

    Others in this thread have some good search ideas but personally I'd start at the top and narrow it down from there.

    If you go to https://www.naco.org/ and click on `county explorer` you can filter the map on a county level across a bunch of different dimensions.

    I'd definitely limit your choice to places with high internet speeds, good education, growing population, high scoring infrastructure, etc.

    Just keep pruning down until you find a few you think you'd like.

    > ideas for cities

    I could list dozens but maybe check out: Beaver, PA; Mason, MI; Wilson, NC; College Station, TX; Macomb, IL

    Assuming your wife is willing to drive some then: Longview, WA; Castle Dale, UT; Wisconsin Rapids, WI;

  • by mitchellst on 8/15/22, 1:59 PM

    One note on small towns: most of the people there aren't transplants, so you get their culture with them. American cities have a reasonably standardized culture, courtesy of hundreds of daily direct flights to each other. Small towns are still highly regional. Not saying there's no difference between Seattle and Miami. But most people on HN could find a social group in both.

    Not so for Muleshoe, Texas.

    If you're from the east coast, you might find the perfect physical scene in Oregon. But be prepared that west coasters are different from you, potentially in important ways that affect your ability to find a sense of belonging. Ditto if you're from California and looking at Georgia. Northerners and southerners, of course, look sideways at each other for lots of political and cultural reasons, but there are plenty of reasons to feel like you do or don't belong in a culture that aren't historically, culturally, or racially charged.

    Most functioning communities consider themselves to have "good schools." Do you share their bar for that? "Good" for what?

    Important questions. Climate isn't he only thing that varies by region. If you don't know the regional culture in an area that interests you, go stay a while.

    (I've lived in the Pacific Northwest, both urban and rural California, both urban and rural Texas, Chicago, and New England, and spent substantial time in NYC and the Deep South. Trust me. It's not all the same.)

  • by scarecrowbob on 8/15/22, 3:56 AM

    Travel. Just book yourself for two month long stays at a bunch of places and see what you like. I tried that but sucked at it and eneded up staying in the first place I did a stint at... but to be fair there are worse places than Colorado's west slope, especially if you bike and climb and ski.

    You say that you just need a bar and a supermarket, but you've probably never lived in, like, Brady, TX or Cuba, NM. Stuff gets small fast, though those are cheap places to live. You can buy amazing houses in defunct oilfeild towns like Pampa, TX. But really, if you have a heart attack there you're in for about an hour drive to get to definitive care.

  • by Falkon1313 on 8/15/22, 10:43 AM

    Yes. The way my wife and I found ours was that on vacation we'd just drive to somewhere we hadn't been, stopping in small towns along the way. When we found a town we liked, we'd get a hotel room or B&B and wander around and explore the town.

    Ended up buying a house in one of those towns that we had passed through on vacation. Within walking distance of everything we need. It's much cheaper than the big city, or even a suburb near a big city.

  • by dcolkitt on 8/15/22, 4:05 AM

    Generally think college towns around land grant universities are a very underrated option. Outside the immediate area around the campus core they tend to be cheap because of an abundance of land. These towns tend to be very educated and cosmopolitan, with maybe not a ton of cultural options but certainly a few high quality ones.
  • by herbst on 8/15/22, 8:49 AM

    I don't know about the culture for this in the US but I live far from any actual shop in the swiss Alps and there are many fridges around that sell all the necessaries for everyday life (milk, cheese, ..). Everything else I order from a farmer shop/supermarket online.

    There are restaurants and bars sure, I would ask myself if you actually need 'shopping'

    Personally I highly prefer to buy only HQ products which I can look into from my couch other than buying whatever the store has in stock.

  • by ogou on 8/15/22, 2:51 PM

    I spent a month driving around the country last year. Be warned that entire counties have been decimated by meth and fentanyl. Low income doesn't always translate to violent crime and theft, but meth absolutely does. When looking at crime maps, always filter by overdose response and not posession arrests. https://money.cnn.com/interactive/news/meth-lab-map/ Absolutely stay away from Tulsa, OK. Greenville, SC is very nice though.
  • by s0rce on 8/15/22, 4:14 AM

    Take a look at the great main street awards: https://www.mainstreet.org/mainstreetamerica/mainstreetaward...

    I'm currently living in Carson City, it has some walkable (older) areas of town but not great. You could try Walla Walla, WA or Baker City, OR.

  • by pontifier on 8/15/22, 3:51 AM

    My method sure hasn't worked very well... or has it? I was looking for cheap warehouse space to start a business in, and did a nation-wide search for the largest, cheapest building in the entire continental US.

    I found one that seemed too good to be true. a 220,000 sqft metal warehouse and office complex on 17 acres. I thought the price was a typo at $375k.The agent assured me that the price was correct, and I flew out to see the place.

    It was in a little town called Pine Bluff, Arkansas.

    I offered about 3/4 what they were asking, and they accepted the offer.

    Fast forward 2 1/2 years, and I've had nothing but problems. Break in after break in. Can't work through the red tape with the city so my warehouse sits empty. It feels like they are actively working against myself and other entrepreneurs I talk to. At least 2 others who bought buildings and tried to open businesses left after getting nowhere.

    Maybe I'm daft, but I ended up buying about 75 more properties here... all surprisingly cheap.

    The town is killing me though. I haven't seen my kids very much lately - I don't think it's safe enough for them. I'm probably going to be moving back to Utah in the next couple of months because it's just too much out here.

  • by xboxnolifes on 8/15/22, 5:05 AM

    When you say "a little downtown area" and "homes you want", what exactly would you specify as being the minimum to satisfy these? I ask, because at least one place I know of exists to some definition of having a downtown, with homes in the $200k-400k range.

    Because if you really just want a home, a supermarket, a few local restaurants, a bar, a few shops, and an airport within an hour drive, some New Jersey areas come to mind.

    But these aren't likely to be dream towns. They will have flaws. Almost certainly will has less walkability than any city you may live in, unless you live on, and never leave, the main strip. There will be less variety in foods, the bar culture you imagine may not be the bar culture that is actually there.

  • by pugworthy on 8/15/22, 3:51 AM

    Corvallis OR.

    Housing costs are higher, but probably not the $1M you mention unless you really want to go overboard.

    Walk to the store, city bus is free, great place to raise kids, bike paths and trails, and you're out of town into the woods or farm fields in 15 minutes of driving. 1 hour to the coast, or 1 hour to the mountains. University as well as HP, NuScale, and other smaller companies.

    People that come here can definitely turn into lifers.

  • by pbuzbee on 8/15/22, 3:41 AM

    I just saw an interactive tool for this recently: https://www.movemap.io/explore/us
  • by MilnerRoute on 8/15/22, 3:08 AM

    If you're looking for an incentive program, here's a place to start looking....

    https://www.makemymove.com/

    I think this site will even contact cities for you that don't have incentive programs.

    Another advantage of these city programs is you're part of a cohort of relocaters - so you always have people sharing the newcomer experience with you.

  • by mkl on 8/15/22, 9:19 AM

    > I don’t drive but like to walk to the supermarket and restaurants.

    This doesn't seem like most small towns would work. Cars become required outside cities in my experience, and small towns mean lots of long drives for basic things.

  • by zxcvbn4038 on 8/15/22, 4:44 AM

    A number of states are offering grants for remote workers to relocate, offers vary but generally you can get monthly installments of around $1k paid out over one or two years. You have to apply and be accepted, be verifiably employed full time, 100% remote, and if you leave within the first couple years you either lose out on the balance of the grant or you might need to pay a portion back.

    The programs are generally designed to bring people into rural areas, you need to pay close attention to make sure there is sufficient internet for you to work remotely. Places like Frontier top out at 1.5mbps, a little further down the road your internet might be line of sight wireless. Then inexplicably the other side of a hill might be top of the line cable internet. You can’t really trust the web sites, they need to come out and confirm an address can be serviced at the speed you need (without you paying them $10,000+ to run cable)

    Oh! Your employer might need to be registered with the state so they can submit your withholdings. You should verify with your HR department which states they can support.

  • by snarf21 on 8/15/22, 12:57 PM

    You should definitely come to Lancaster PA!!!!

    There are lots of houses downtown for less than $400K and even new "luxury" condos going up everywhere. There is a convenient train that can have you in Philly in an hour for <$20. (also goes to NY) You can be in Baltimore and DC in a few hours and you can be in the Poconos for skiing in the same time. There is the oldest continuously operating farmer's market downtown. (and tons outside the city) There is a thriving art scene (and college). There are tons of ethnic restaurants (there are a lot of relief and refugee orgs). You can be at the beach in two or three hours (depending which one). There are tons of outlets for shopping east of town if that's your thing. There is very little traffic except for 3 specific bottlenecks that you'll learn to avoid. There is a thriving tech community with several weekly meetups that discuss new tech at a local bar.

    Come live with the cool kids.

    (Source: I live in Lancaster and there is no place better net net)

  • by matt_s on 8/15/22, 3:25 AM

    Just pick any mid sized US city and pick a suburb that has a Main Street type of area and it’s not in high COL area. I would look for ones with fiber internet available. The houses should not be anywhere near $1m when you do this. Avoid high tax states like CA or NY.

    I imagine you have other factors like distance from family, area of the country, weather, proximity to mountains/beach/parks/major metro for things to do, etc. so those should narrow down what states. Then go on a mini vacation and explore or work remotely from where you’re exploring.

  • by 13of40 on 8/15/22, 4:29 AM

    IMHO, I think Hawaii would be a good place to do this. One issue with Hawaii for people used to living in other latitudes is that the sun basically sets at 6:00 PM every day, all year, so if you worked a nine to five job there you'd be getting off right before the sun went down. However, if you got up at 4:00 AM and worked in sync with people on the mainland until early afternoon, then you could get off and have a few hours of daylight to hit the beach or whatever else.
  • by christophilus on 8/15/22, 11:45 AM

    Every state I’ve lived in had great small towns. Most recently, I’ve been in NC and SC (finally settled in the latter). I say buy an old school road atlas, rent a car, and take a long road trip.

    The town that inspired Andy Griffith’s Mayberry is in the mountains of NC (or maybe it was VA). Stuff like that is all over the place here.

    As for me, I chose a small, walkable town that isn’t too far from Greenville, SC (which is itself considered to be a small, walkable town by some folks).

  • by basyl on 8/15/22, 4:12 AM

    I'd also check how the place is bound to be impacted by climate change, e.g. https://coastal.climatecentral.org/

    You don't want to end up in a coastal city just to find yourself under 1m of water in a few years!

  • by sharno on 8/15/22, 2:12 PM

    I have a feeling that many towns in Rhode Island might fit your criteria here. The state's culture is generally about things being close to each other as any driving more than 30 min will get you out of the state anyway. Having BOS airport an hour drive away is a blessing too. It's cold in winter though. But I'd say you kinda get used to it.
  • by cssanchez on 8/15/22, 4:08 AM

    You should consider Puerto Rico. The entire island has a small town feel, but the west coast is mostly what you describe. There's also great weather and tax benefits.
  • by orangetuba on 8/15/22, 8:02 AM

    There are many reasons why college towns are great, but particularly this one:

    In small towns, people are very nosy, and it gets incredibly tiring after a while. People stare at you and look you up and down. Except, when it's a college town, because they're used to having strangers around.

  • by poulsbohemian on 8/16/22, 3:27 AM

    In 2010 I moved from near a US tech hub to a small town 5 hours away. There are lots of pros and cons, but main thing I'd say is to be honest with yourself about your economic situation and your lifestyle needs, and don't make the jump lightly. Within just a few years I looked around and realized that all the young families our age that we'd met had packed up their bags and left because they couldn't make it work economically + job opportunities were greater elsewhere. Yes a lot has changed especially re: covid and remote work, but it's still way easier to find work if you are in a tech hub or major city.

    Especially now being a real estate agent (which in itself is a story of the changes that come with small town life...), I meet lots of people of all demographics moving into our area. Many have never spent any time here, but are drawn to the pictures in the tourist magazine, so to speak. I'm already starting to see people who bought during covid lockdowns who are now having buyers remorse as they realize that maybe small town life isn't for them. All I'm saying is, do more than spend a weekend in a place before you decide to buy a house and shake up your life - I've legit seen people buy houses having basically never been here, and that's not a wise approach.

    Frankly, if you really have the means and don't have family ties keeping you in a place, I'd ask: why stay in the US at all? But regardless of where you go, hone your research in quickly. Don't keep looking at every last little burg in all 50 states. Go rent an airbnb for a couple of weeks and live as though you live there - and make yourself a study of the tradeoffs you'd be making with each place.

  • by w1 on 8/15/22, 3:39 AM

    Emporia, KS.

    Home of a small college and a few large obscure athletic events (Unbound Gravel and disc golf nationals). Kansas is also a very reasonable state, politically, compared to much of the midwest. Less than two hours from decent sized airports (MCI and Wichita).

  • by davidw on 8/15/22, 3:38 AM

    I think 'decent airport' is perhaps tricky, at least on the west coast. I think you'll need to be more specific about some other things like how small is too small or how big is too big, and what 'cold' means for you. This site seems to have some good search facilities: https://www.bestplaces.net/

    Also agree with the 'college towns' comment.

  • by jason-phillips on 8/15/22, 12:53 PM

    I went through this exercise pre-COVID. I started working remotely in 2017 as I had 17 years of experience at that point. I left Austin and moved to a small town in 2018 that's two hours west of Austin.

    > Any ideas on whether this mid-sized town dream exists...

    Sure it exists.

    > ...and/or how we’d go about finding it?

    Sure, you need to do your research and figure that out for yourself. I researched on the internet for about 18 months and did a lot of boots-on-the-ground investigation. I eventually moved to a small town in the Texas Hill Country that I adore. Low crime, very clean and beautiful environment, low cost of living, absolutely fantastic community and gigabit fiber internet.

    I then bought a second, larger home in a small town a little closer to Austin that is logistically a little more convenient and not so remote. But again, it has low crime, a local hospital, HEB grocery store, fantastic community and gigabit fiber internet.

    Just do your research. It's not so hard but it will take a little time.

    The peace and quiet combined with the cost of living is priceless. I couldn't be happier. I love it out here.

  • by prennert on 8/15/22, 7:29 PM

    Find data sources and optimise for your objectives. For me it was:

    - travel-time, via connections like airports, train stations, motorways, etc. You will need them when you want to travel, or your spouse needs to get to an office

    - weather. Now and predictions of how it will change in the future

    - water levels and flood risks and how they are predicted to change over your lifetime (especially important of you like the coast, rivers, etc.)

    - forest fires, draught etc might be a factor depending on your climate

    - proximity to industrial or academic centers

    - general social-economic situation of the place that is interesting to you

    Most of this data is likely freely available from public / state sources.

    If you don't know the place, rent first, buy when you are happy. Data is unlikely to provide the full picture and you need to live in a place to get a full picture of it's quirks. Make sure to use the facilities you care about to get an idea how they work in practice.

  • by scythe on 8/15/22, 12:13 PM

    >We’d likely both be happier in a town, living just off some Main Street with 20 or so shops. The city is great but honestly I don’t need more than a good diner, a supermarket, and a friendly bar. Nice to haves are a pleasant climate (not too cold), an airport within an hour or so, and decent public schools.

    Study. You can type "Las Cruces NM climate" into Google and get a free graph. You know your interests better than any of us, and you can look at local event listings, restaurants, venues etc to see what's a good fit. Zillow will tell you about schools and crime, and airports are on the map.

    When people go by word-of-mouth based on where other people went, you get a situation where everyone moves to Denver^W Austin^W Nashville, and then it isn't fun anymore. Nobody goes there, it's too crowded. Especially when the discussion is on the Internet.

  • by foxyv on 8/15/22, 3:59 PM

    The two major funders for small towns are military bases and colleges. Small college towns are stabilized by a steady stream of federal money from student loans and subsidies. They will often have better services and healthier businesses. The same goes for military towns that get a ton of money from soldiers spending cash and buying/renting housing.

    Small towns that are supported by companies and agriculture have been drained dry by corporate greed. Jobs have been off-shored and taxes have been almost completely avoided. Sometimes a town is supported by a major military contractor, but they aren't terribly dependable. Some places are supported by retirees, but they aren't nearly as affordable.

    So if you want to look for a stable small town, look for towns near universities, colleges, or military bases.

  • by protomyth on 8/15/22, 3:32 AM

    Check a bandwidth map so you are not frustrated. You probably also want to make sure the politicians in the area are of your preferred party since that will tell you if your family will have people with your beliefs in the area. Being the odd person out from the local folks isn't fun.
  • by hax0rbana on 8/15/22, 5:58 AM

    You have at least some of your requirements already. Pick a few candidate towns and scope them out (home prices, weather, healthcare, public transit, culture, local hangouts, art, whatever appeals to you).

    When you think you found a good one, go visit in person and see if it meets expectations.

    If you want a specific instance, check out Champaign-Urbana, IL. There's Research Park, the University of Illinois, a bunch of bars and restaurants, fun art sprinkled around town, gigabit fiber and homes are under $200K. We walk to the grocery store with our wagon and just fill it up instead of using a shopping cart. If you come visit, be sure to check out Black Dog (a barbeque joint). https://yourewelcomecu.com/

  • by duped on 8/15/22, 3:09 AM

    Try the Midwest around rail commuter routes. Most of them developed small yet thriving downtowns that are quite quaint and affordable

    For example check out Geneva Illinois

  • by radiojasper on 8/17/22, 10:33 AM

    Move to The Netherlands and you can suddenly walk everywhere. Also it's rather easy to get into NL with the Dutch American Friendship Treaty. [0]

    The only thing you need is a company in NL and keeping $4500 on your bank account. Registering a company in NL is as easy as buying milk. One visit to the Chamber of Commerce [1] and you're good.

    [0] https://dutchamericanfriendship.com/

    [1] https://www.kvk.nl

  • by danwee on 8/15/22, 8:27 AM

    Anything near to the Canada border? I'm thinking about climate change, and I have changed drastically the idea of " where my future home" will be. In 10-20 years things will get worse I imagine.
  • by shrubble on 8/15/22, 4:36 AM

    The warning I would make about PA is about their road system, which is tremendously, comically, confusing (every road has at least a name and a number) and leads to driving taking so much longer than you would think.

    Lancaster PA: drive from Park City Mall to the center of Lancaster City, which is the Greist Building, the tallest in the area (has many telecom antennas there) and is near the Fulton Opera House. On the map, it shows 3.5 miles as you pass by Long's Park. Unless it is in the middle of the night, you will be lucky to make it in less than 20 minutes.

  • by spaetzleesser on 8/15/22, 3:40 AM

    New Mexico has a bunch of nice small towns. I live in Albuquerque (not a small town but there are quite a few others) and I have some shops, restaurants and bars all in walking distance.
  • by ltbarcly3 on 8/15/22, 3:50 AM

    I just moved to Ocean Springs, MS from Los Gatos, CA. We have been looking for about a year, this is the place that checked the most boxes for us. Most places we were looking at either had terrible schools (Alaska, apart from like 3 magnet schools) or were very remote (Islesboro, ME) Very happy I got out of CA before PG&E killed my family (we had a fire break out in June about 100 meters from my front door, if it had been windy we had 0 chance of escape as it would have blocked all the roads to our house. This forces us to bite the bullet and make the move, and Ocean Springs was top of our list).

    Great schools, very progressive area (at least for MS). No homeless people leaving needles in the streets or throwing poop at me. Quite humid! 5Gb/s fiber to my house from multiple competing providers. Paid way way way below $1M (way below $500k lol) for 2500sft house with a huge yard, walking distance to the gulf of mexico (and a nice beach area) and about a mile from dozens of downtown restaurants. 10 minute drive to Biloxi and casinos and other nightlife. I have lost count of the number of people who have gone down my street on bikes or jogging (or on golf carts, which are street legal here). Gulf Islands National Seashore's entrance is less than half a mile away.

  • by wikitopian on 8/15/22, 11:38 AM

    French Lick, Indiana is a tiny town in the middle of nowhere that some billionaire invested his fortune in renovating a historic hotel, building up a resort casino, and fleshing out the downtown into a charming experience. There's even a ski resort nearby.

    And it's all at rock bottom prices.

    Louisville airport is about an hour away, and since it's a major UPS hub, it's quite nicer than the population of the area would otherwise support.

  • by tonfreed on 8/15/22, 6:44 AM

    You also have to remember that the culture is very different in the country. If you've been a city person for a long time, you're probably going to struggle to make any friends until you start acting like the locals.

    Not so prevalent in a city where there's enough people to form smaller subcommunities, but in a small town you can't really do that and will need to put in effort to fit in.

  • by trcarney on 8/15/22, 7:02 PM

    The first place that came to mid is Northwest Arkansas, especially Bentonville. It still has a small town feel but has much nicer amenities than a town of its size normally does because of all the money brought in by Walmart being headquartered there. The surrounding towns, Fayetteville especially, are also nice. This place is especially awesome if you are into doing things outdoors, especially mountain biking.

    Another place to expand your search are these YouTube channels, From Here to There (https://www.youtube.com/c/FromHeretoThere/videos) and The World According To Briggs (https://www.youtube.com/c/WorldAccordingToBriggs). They might help find places your aren't currently looking at.

  • by bbatha on 8/15/22, 3:56 PM

    I've been fulltime remote for a few years, and just moved to Lancaster, PA. I'm loving it here. Its enough of a city that I'm not missing the amenities or multi-cultural atmosphere. The housing prices are great, and I can get to my NYC office very easily on the train or even driving. I'm very happy to have moved.
  • by NickSingh on 8/15/22, 12:23 PM

    College towns I found have been great for this - things to do, access to airports and good schools, top-notch hospitals usually in the middle of "nowhere". Look into Charlottesville, Virginia - went to UVA and loved the town. Have also heard good things about Ithaca NY, Champaign IL, and Ann Arbor MI.
  • by webwright on 8/17/22, 4:22 PM

    20 or so shops isn't mid-sized, is it?

    I just moved to Orcas Island in the PNW after living in cities (Seattle, Anchorage) for most of my adult life. I'm near the one town on the island (which is REALLY quiet outside of the 4 warmest/touristy months). ~4,500 people year round population. Weather is perfect with near zero rain for 4-6 months but a bit gray / drizzly for the rest. It's rarely cold, but decent ski hills are 2h inland.

    The population (like a lot of small towns) is pretty old, but I found the small group of newer folks (lots of tech expats) to be really welcoming.

    I can walk to the small airport, which has regular $180-$200 flights to Seattle (show up 10min before departure, 45min flight). Ferries are more work but sometimes you want your vehicle on the mainland for a big group of houseguests or whatnot.

    I'm 15min away from getting a paddlboard into two mountain lakes-- both are popular swimming destinations for locals. I have friends pulling crabs and prawns out of the water all summer. There are zillions of islands and inlets around-- it's a playground if you're a boater. 4-5 good hikes on the islands with breathtaking views. There's one (never crowded) gym in town with a racquetball court. There's a board game meetup. A few fancy restaurants, one killer cocktail bar, a good locals dive bar. I leave my door unlocked. There's a "village green" with frequent concerts and a Saturday farmer's market. The schools and kids on this island are amazing. Ferries and small planes can get you quickly to Victoria/Vancouver Island, Vancouver (the city), and assorted other cool small/medium towns.

    I'm pretty new to this, but am LOVING it. There are downsides-- not a lot of food variety in town, tough to make new friends if you aren't the kind of person who makes the effort. The gray season is long and VERY quiet, so you definitely need to budget time/$ to travel. The schools are pretty understanding about missed days in the winter because of this.

    Hit me up if you (or anyone) ever wants to check it out. I'll buy you a drink and talk your ear off about it.

  • by emiliobumachar on 8/15/22, 10:40 AM

    If you want an airliner airport with a wide selection of time and destination options, as opposed to somewhere to base your private airplane, consider starting the search around those. Look in the opposite direction than the big city it serves. And beware of noise issues caused by the airport itself.
  • by fastball on 8/15/22, 9:02 AM

    One of the main sites many (most?) "digital nomads" go for such information is Nomadlist[1], though this might be a little less US / small town-centric than what you're looking for.

    [1] https://nomadlist.com/

  • by telebell on 8/15/22, 4:13 AM

    West Chester or Kennett Square, PA, especially if you were already considering Lancaster. Both fit the bill.
  • by s5300 on 8/15/22, 3:23 AM

    Check out smallish public research university college towns.

    Ohio University is a pretty cool place, though slightly secluded.

  • by matthewcwise on 8/15/22, 4:43 PM

    I’ve been playing around with some data to try to answer this for myself. It’s still very work-in-progress so I’d love feedback from you and others—you can explore the data at https://myplace.guru
  • by shusaku on 8/15/22, 11:18 AM

    Consider Muffy Aldrich’s list of “New England Preppy Towns”

    https://www.saltwaternewengland.com/2022/07/new-england-prep...

  • by bombcar on 8/15/22, 3:45 AM

    There was a map tool that would show you every place within an hour of a major airport - but I would limit myself to airports that are a hub for an airline or otherwise "large" - Burbank would be ok, Santa Barbara not by my theory.

    Then I'd look for towns that have had the population grow in the last decade, or at least stay level, towns that are dropping in population often have issues (though if everything else about it seems right, check it out).

    And then I'd visit - stay at a hotel for a week and see what it's like, if it seems good consider a longer stay. I would visit in the "worst" part of the year, not the best! So if you're looking at Duluth you'd visit in the winter, not in spring or fall.

  • by suprjami on 8/15/22, 11:01 AM

    > restaurants > 20 or so shops

    Forget eating out. We just moved from a city of 2.5M to a town of 1500, the next biggest town over has 3000. The thing we miss the most is the variety of food, especially Asian food. However that's all we miss and the benefits are many.

  • by inrhafi on 8/15/22, 12:53 PM

    I’ll let you in on a little secret in the middle of California, it’s hot, but it’s an affordable little town, with just the amenities you mention. I know because I lived there most of my life. The town is Exeter.

    Like I said, it’s hot there over the summer, and it’s the red middle of a blue state, but the people are very kind. They have an absolutely wonderful coffee shop downtown, a tiny brewery and pub across the street, a couple nice super markets (not so walkable), and some gas station/markets that are very walkable. We lived five minutes from downtown in a neighborhood. We paid $215k for our house, in 2015, so I’d imagine that price has gone up quite a bit, but it’s definitely affordable.

  • by spudlyo on 8/15/22, 4:41 AM

    Olympia WA. Home to The Evergreen State College, Washington State Capitol, and Sea-Tac International is just under an hour away. Winters are mild, but very wet. Violent crime (20.4) is under the national average, while property crime is nearly twice the national average at 61.2.

    I grew up in the Thurston County area in the 80s, and went to school at TESC, a hippie liberal arts college I remember the downtown as being charming, with lots of hip cafes, bars, and restaurants. I've considered moving back there myself. That said, in recent years epidemics of homelessness and drug addiction have taken a bit of a toll on the city, but I still think it's worth checking out.

  • by tlianza on 8/15/22, 4:28 AM

    Seems like a useful app idea. Probably not something that would get much repeat use though.
  • by cbanek on 8/15/22, 7:15 AM

    Just wait a bit and see what happens in the housing market. I'm not saying it's ready for a crash, but sometimes renting for a year means everything will change. You can rent in a small town (cheap) or just stay where you are at for a while.

    Everyone is thinking like you during the pandemic when remote work was the norm. That pushed up housing prices in weird places, like Boise, and other places like Sedona. Places that are small, typically tourist places, but very nice and pretty. The lack of housing has pushed up prices to ridiculous levels, but once the market corrects, it'll be a different world.

  • by lovetocode on 8/15/22, 2:44 PM

    Honestly -- I think you will be disappointed. The market wrecked everyone who was trying to buy. I live in a town of 70k and I got priced out of my own neighborhood -- and I make good money. Just because it is a small town, doesn't mean you are going to get bottom of the barrel prices. For example, a 3000sqft home in my area goes for $515k and you have to bring extra money to closing to be even competitive. The areas with smaller homes are _less_ than desirable to be in so don't think you will be getting a good deal there because you are just as likely to get robbed in your front yard.
  • by KingOfCoders on 8/15/22, 4:03 AM

    We moved from Berlin to the Baltic Sea last year (after 20+ years) because remote allowed us to do so, and we love it. And the home was much cheaper. So I can't help you with a city, but encourage you to move forward.
  • by sheepdog on 8/15/22, 2:11 PM

    We did something similar with a move to Columbus, GA. Cost of living was super-low, but 200k people means you get theater, airport, etc.

    One thing to keep in mind as you get older: smaller places may not have all the medical facilities you need. For example, if you get an unusual cancer or need a transplant, your family will be regularly shuttling you 2-3 hours to the nearest large city.

    I think that being ~50-60 minutes south of Atlanta would be nice. It's small enough, but you can hop right up to one of the world's busiest airports and get a flight to about anywhere.

  • by giantg2 on 8/15/22, 3:35 PM

    If you live near Lancaster, you could start driving a horse and buggy.

    I think you'd have to elaborate on what you think a good school is and what a good climate is. It certainly gets cold for part of the year in PA and MD. It can be quite humid in the summers too. I've heard it can be tough to find a "good" public school in parts of SC (I looked at some SC and NC schools when I entertained the idea of moving there a decade ago. The scores were considerably lower than most MD and most PA were).

  • by codingdave on 8/15/22, 3:59 PM

    It definitely exists, but there are so many small towns across the country, we could not possibly list them all. You need to narrow it down - do some road trips, explore regions and states, and pick a target area. Maybe choose a big city you might want to be within a few hours of. Then get a realtor from that city to educate you on the towns in the area and help you narrow down to a few actual potential locations. Then you can start looking at homes.
  • by listenupyall on 8/16/22, 2:28 AM

    In the pat seven years I traveled the western part of the US a lot with my camper and if I had to live in the US (I am Dutch and currently live on Curacao) I would probably go for Frisco, Colorado. But I am pretty outdoorsy so that’s a big part of why I would like to live there. Not to big, not to small, year round outdoor activities, an hours drive from Denver and an overall good vibe.
  • by dncornholio on 8/15/22, 9:49 AM

    Probably not the answer you want, but the EU is literally filled with towns like this. Cycling and public transport can get you and your kids anywhere.
  • by NiagaraThistle on 8/15/22, 1:27 PM

    I'm not sure if it would have small to midsize towns like you are looking for, but Nomadlist might be a good place to start as it is a curation of popular places for nomads (and no by extension remote workers) to relocate to. It uses a LOT of filters to weed out places you don't want and find the places that hit your "must haves" so it might be worth a quick look.
  • by __derek__ on 8/16/22, 1:44 AM

    Check out the site Make Me Move[1], which lists towns offering incentives for remote workers to move there. Some offers are nominal (e.g., co-working space memberships), but there are some nice towns actively looking to attract and support folks like you.

    [1]: https://www.makemymove.com/

  • by binwiederhier on 8/15/22, 3:43 AM

    Fairfield, CT -- it's not cheap, but it's got charm and few beaches. Been living here for 6 years and we love it.
  • by suhastech on 8/15/22, 4:10 AM

    I have experimented with a lot of different types of living situations during the pandemic - mountain tourist towns, suburban areas, countryside. At the end of the day, I felt the most fulfilled when I was able to connect with a community. I've had better luck with acceptance when they, themselves, are new to the community.
  • by bitcoinmoney on 8/16/22, 7:20 AM

    Anybody have answer to the question but add constraint about diversity? Especially being non Caucasian?
  • by jimlawruk on 8/15/22, 6:33 PM

    We moved from DC to Camp Hill, PA for similar reasons. Camp Hill has a decent walkable/bikable community (stores, schools, etc.) Harrisburg is the capital so it has just enough going on. I miss DC for sure, but it is nice to have an affordable house and a less complex lifestyle.
  • by JackFr on 8/15/22, 12:43 PM

    Just from what I know anecdotally, you’re going to do best in college towns or vacation spots. And while that doesn’t preclude affordable homes, it means you might not get the pick of the litter.

    The economics of supporting a walkable downtown are just real tough in many places.

  • by dogline on 8/15/22, 1:58 PM

    Now sure what to make of "I live in a ~1000 pop town" yet can be in a bigger town in 10 minutes via car (in the East), and "I live in a ~1000 pop town" and it's 45 min to anything (in N. CA and the west). (Have lived in both.)
  • by vlunkr on 8/15/22, 1:00 PM

    Just know that wherever you go, people will probably complain, even if it’s behind your back. I don’t think it’s justified, but I hear lots of problems attributed to “California people” moving in.

    I think complaining about any change is just part of small town America.

  • by ulfw on 8/15/22, 3:38 AM

    How about Bozeman, Montana? 50K people small but got pretty much everything you'd need.
  • by ipnon on 8/15/22, 3:48 AM

    Best way to do this is to find a place on your own. Take off a few weeks, or months, from work and drive across the country. Make it to every corner you can. Eventually you’ll stumble across some little town that feels more homely than the rest.
  • by quickthrower2 on 8/15/22, 9:26 AM

    This is where the UK is great. It has lots of well connected by train towns. You can commute for a night out in London but live a generally quiet life in anything from a tiny hamlet to something like Cambridge which is a small city.
  • by jollyllama on 8/15/22, 3:23 PM

    Pick somewhere:

    that you fit in politically or that your values match, otherwise you could be viewed as an outside agitator.

    where agriculture is feasible, preferably with as little non-local inputs as possible (i.e. water)

  • by pheasant3 on 8/15/22, 3:42 AM

    Wyoming! Move to Wyoming lads. Reconnect with nature and quiet.

    Towns near the Tetons. Jackson of course is crazy expensive, but the towns nearby are amazing.

    And the place is more progressive that you might think - for WY

  • by zeroth32 on 8/15/22, 7:47 AM

    I am DN, I follow pensioners, they usually live in boring accessible cities. There was documentary about some town in US, where people mostly use golf carts to get around.
  • by journey_16162 on 8/15/22, 9:23 AM

  • by skoocda on 8/16/22, 8:15 PM

  • by stevenalowe on 8/15/22, 9:48 PM

    In most US places get too rural and your worklifeline (internet service) options thin rapidly

    Will be interesting to see if/how starlink changes this

  • by rwultsch on 8/15/22, 2:49 PM

    We recently moved to Frederick, MD. Walking distance to the very lively downtown, inexpensive housing, close to an airport, yada, yada...
  • by MauroIksem on 8/17/22, 4:07 AM

    People like you are destroying other people's ability to live in their small towns..they don't want you.
  • by xtiansimon on 8/15/22, 11:47 AM

    Got internet? How about healthcare options?

    Intersect that data with crime and population.

    Sounds like a cool data project.

  • by throwaway6734 on 8/15/22, 2:19 PM

    Asbury Park NJ is on the beach, pretty small, and a train ride away from nyc
  • by xupybd on 8/15/22, 8:59 AM

    Move to New Zealand. We're full of small towns with great life styles.
  • by pneumatic1 on 8/15/22, 11:09 AM

    We considered:

    Lansing, MI

    Chapel Hill, NC

    Wilmington, NC

    *Ithaca, NY*

  • by sneak on 8/15/22, 4:02 AM

    Without a symphony/opera, theater, decent concert venue, and some art museums, life is going to get real boring, real fast.

    I did a stint in a cheap culture wasteland through covid. It may be economically cheaper but the toll it takes on your soul is real.

  • by braingenious on 8/15/22, 3:35 AM

    Grafton, New Hampshire
  • by RonaldOlzheim on 8/15/22, 9:04 AM

    Is there a dedicated website for this somewhere?
  • by atarian on 8/15/22, 3:50 AM

    Bend, Oregon
  • by freemint on 8/15/22, 2:59 PM

    Look along old railway lines.
  • by rythmshifter on 8/16/22, 2:31 AM

    I chose three rivers mi
  • by pzd on 8/15/22, 3:45 AM

    Johnson City, TN
  • by notatoad on 8/15/22, 4:50 AM

    If you are just looking for a cheaper city, you're going to be disappointed by any small town. "A friendly bar" is kind of a big ask in a small town that might only have a couple bars. There could easily not be one that you like. Same with schools - in a city you have choice, in a small town you are going to end up with whatever the local school is. Maybe it's good. Maybe it isn't. And maybe the town that has a friendly bar doesn't have a good school.

    Honestly, it sounds like you belong in a city. A town isn't just a collection of perfect versions of the things you like from your city, and cheaper housing. That isn't going to exist. The bars will be worse. The schools will probably be worse. The stores will be further away, or else the housing "just off main street" will he more expensive. The social opportunities will be fewer. If you want to be happy with small town life, you need to find the advantages that exist only in towns and not cities: Outdoor recreation opportunities, family to be closer to, or non-social things you can do on your own with more space like gardening.

  • by voydik on 8/15/22, 4:43 AM

    Go to Montana.
  • by chaosbutters314 on 8/15/22, 4:09 AM

    Ithaca NY
  • by luckyhn on 8/15/22, 3:46 AM

    > I don’t need more than a good diner, a supermarket, and a friendly bar.

    You'd better be sure about that. Having a favorite diner, grocer and bar and only patronizing those businesses is a world apart from having exactly one option. What do you do when the bartender/regulars decide they don't like you. Or your neighbor, for that matter. The one whose family's been there for generations and is buds with the sherrif.

    IMO you should find another suburb that you and your wife like. There are major downsides to small town living you're probably not taking seriously.

  • by daedlanth on 8/15/22, 9:26 AM

    Go Away
  • by e-clinton on 8/15/22, 11:49 AM

    I’d get a dozen aggressive rottweilers and let them lose in there.
  • by mikewarot on 8/15/22, 10:18 AM

    The type of town you want was made illegal to build about a century ago, so your best bet is old towns near water that somehow survived deindustrialization.