from Hacker News

Ask HN: What is your dream Smart classroom setup?

by venmul on 8/2/22, 6:04 AM with 4 comments

• by runjake on 8/2/22, 9:09 PM

  Classes are already using iPads, smart projectors, and in some cases, dipping their toes into AR.

  I think the most effective thing would be to ensure a "1-to-1" student/device ratio, which the pandemic has inadvertently helped happen -- at least in the US, by and large. Every kid has a computer. Schools just need to budget appropriately to replenish those devices when they hit end-of-life. A large portion of the (any) population has no computer at home.

  Do that first, then worry about implementing programs for hard skills (Career Technical Education, electronics, robotics, programming, CAD, automotive, Maker, etc), then make sure kids have appropriate meals, and then finally, if you have any money left over, bring in the whiz-bang tech.

• by sethammons on 8/2/22, 10:45 AM

  As a former math teacher, I was excited to do interactive math and graphing programs on the more advanced ti-nspire and cas system. Super cool! And I got rid of it as soon as I could. We spent more time making them work than using them. Kids don't "auto know how to tech" so it was just IT support instead of TI learning.

  The one that I loved was the tablet / whiteboard projector. Like a wacom tablet and I could walk around and teach from the rear of the class when appropriate. However, most of the teachers struggled using it because you look at the wall and not your hand when writing.

  In the end, the best tech is a decent whiteboard. Uhg. I've become the former generation.

• by aynyc on 8/2/22, 11:57 AM

  As a parent dealing with endless digital distractions, no smart device would be my preference unless it’s related to course work. I’m not sure if my way is the correct way in these days.

• by euroderf on 8/2/22, 3:16 PM

  How about a GSM jammer. Here in Finland, kids can keep their devices at their desks - cos you know, "family emergency" crapola. So they sit and tinker.