from Hacker News

The sheer size of our government workforce is an alarming problem (2019)

by hncurious on 12/17/21, 1:57 AM with 8 comments

  • by ruytlm on 12/17/21, 2:45 AM

    (2019), but also this is an opinion piece that makes a lot of claims without any evidence beyond the libertarian ideology of its author.

    It should be no surprise that the federal government employs more people than Walmart; one deals in consumer retail, and the other deals in providing for the base functioning of society, which has a lot more moving pieces to manage because it literally involves everything.

    >"Government needs to be nimble rather than creating perverse incentives for higher compensation for work that could be done in more productive sectors of the economy."

    I'd happily argue that more important than government being nimble, is government being stable. Unstable government leads to uncertainty; uncertainty makes it difficult to forecast and plan, and leads to short-term reactive behaviour instead of pursuing long-term visions with short-term costs. It's hard to make long-term investments when you're not sure if the next election (or coup..) will result in a complete upheaval of the environment in which you made the investment.

    >"Government is a neutral party to uphold contracts and ensure general public safety."

    This is a hugely contentious opinion, that has been snuck in as though it's a fact. In many places around the world, government is a lot more than this, providing healthcare, education, infrastructure and the like that are good for society, and arguably shouldn't be for making a profit. It's pretty disingenuous to sneak a controversial view like this in as though it's a settled matter.

  • by authed on 12/17/21, 2:03 AM

    police/army is probably 90% of it? if you include the black budget
  • by sgwealti on 12/17/21, 2:43 AM

    2019