from Hacker News

Wikipedia Age Challenges Scholars’ Sacred Peer Review

by madebylaw on 8/23/10, 10:09 PM with 1 comments

  • by wmf on 8/23/10, 10:19 PM

    Speaking as both a reviewer and victim of peer review, having only 3-4 reviews for a paper seems to introduce a significant element of luck, so getting more reviews sounds like a good idea. Also, making submissions public can help locate reviewers with very specific expertise (although those people are often competitors).