from Hacker News

Ask HN: Which closed-source software would you most like to see the code for?

by rxlim on 5/21/17, 3:03 PM with 32 comments

I would choose Winamp 2 as the early versions of Winamp is exactly how I think software should be, and I also have great memories with it.
  • by toomuchtodo on 5/21/17, 7:32 PM

    - US air traffic control software

    - Software that drives the NYSE and NASDAQ exchanges

    - SpaceX Dragon vehicle controller (primarily what calculates the boostback trajectory on the fly)

    EDIT: Honorable mention: The Knight Capital codebase [1]

    Disclaimer: Please lawd don't let this put my on a watch list.

    [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-08-02/knight-sh...

  • by zbuf on 5/21/17, 8:24 PM

    Renoise, music production software.

    I've found it to be exceptionally stable and responsive; changes propagate with live feedback right throughout the GUI.

    I'd really like to see if its qualities are the result of great software design, or just brute force and hammering away at it until the bugs are gone. It strikes me it would be hard to achieve with the latter.

    If the architecture is good, whether it is a textbook use of C++ with objects, inheritance and templates, or something more modest/bespoke.

  • by futhey on 5/21/17, 7:28 PM

    Early versions of Google would be interesting to see (would be interesting to look at parts of a version of the engine that are still small enough to reason about).
  • by zbuf on 5/21/17, 8:29 PM

    The code that runs my dad's pacemaker.

    Whether he (or I) would sleep at night after seeing it...

  • by jazztoken on 5/21/17, 8:29 PM

    Dwarf fortress. Incredibly complicated simulation and procgen code written by a guy who admits to having very little engineering knowledge.
  • by axonic on 5/22/17, 1:44 AM

    The firmware from the international version of the Samsung Galaxy S3 which has unexplainable access to storage devices and such while the phone is powered down. I wanna know what was really going on there...
  • by soulchild37 on 5/21/17, 11:13 PM

    Roller Coaster Tycoon, to this date it still amaze me that Chris Sawyer wrote almost the whole game using Assembly
  • by smilesnd on 5/22/17, 12:26 PM

    All the video games blizzard makes specially Starcraft 2 and Overwatch. They just seem to not struggle in lag department as other games. And for the massive world World of Warcraft it keeps state amazingly compare to other mmorpg's. Plus the networking seems to be a step above most.
  • by Tyrannosaur on 5/22/17, 12:07 AM

    The engine behind Opera up until 2013: Presto. I understand why they moved to Blink, but I liked Presto so much better... The current Opera has the same memory issues Chrome does, and it is nowhere close to feature parity as the 2012 version.

    An open source release would let the community help keep up development

  • by whyagaindavid on 5/21/17, 7:39 PM

    XP. Would love if somebody continued development in open way!
  • by violinist on 5/21/17, 7:00 PM

    Visual studio. I've heard that its design is beautiful and I think I'd learn a lot reading it.
  • by demarq on 5/22/17, 5:25 AM

    Sublime text!! I use it all the time
  • by Artlav on 5/21/17, 11:16 PM

    The one that runs the NSA's servers policing the internet.
  • by ReligiousFlames on 5/22/17, 1:17 AM

    VMware Fusion userland & kexts to see how they intercept IOKit USB connections.
  • by jetti on 5/22/17, 3:55 PM

    I would really be interested in seeing the source for IDA Pro. I would love to see how it interacts with each operating system.
  • by saimiam on 5/21/17, 6:34 PM

    Off topic but it's heartening to me that after 3 hours, this thread has no replies. To me, this could be because of two reasons -

    1. People believe most of their favorite softwares are already open source OR 2. They don't think highly enough of closed source softwares to want to know their internals

  • by HaoZeke on 5/21/17, 6:56 PM

    Matlab of course.
  • by FullMtlAlcoholc on 5/21/17, 10:53 PM

    Bayonetta or thr Ai code from F. E. A. R.
  • by fuzzycapacitor on 5/22/17, 6:35 AM

    The firmware for the radio on my phone. Ideally I'd like it to be free software, not merely readable.
  • by thomastjeffery on 5/21/17, 8:12 PM

    To me, this is the wrong question. I don't want software to be open source so I can read it. I want my software to be free (as in liberty), so I can decide how to use it, rather than it use me.